Common caregiver hiring mistakes, and how to avoid them
By Scott McKenzie, founder of Home Care Agency Blueprint · Updated
Most hiring problems come from skipping a step, treating candidates differently, or missing a notice the law requires. Here are the mistakes worth avoiding, each with the rule or source behind it.
Mistakes to avoid
Posting the job before checking state caregiver rules
Some states require background checks, registry listings or training before client contact. Learn your state’s steps first, so your job ad and timeline match them.
Your own planning
A job ad that signals a preference
Ads that seek “females” or “recent college graduates” are the EEOC’s examples of ads that may violate the law. Describe the work, not the worker.
Recruiting only by word of mouth
Relying only on referrals from a workforce made up mostly of one group may violate the law. Use referrals alongside open postings.
Different questions for different candidates
Unstructured interviews are hard to compare and easy to challenge. Ask every candidate for the same job the same questions.
Your own planning
Medical or family questions in the interview
Disability-related questions are not allowed before a conditional job offer, and questions about marriage or children can be evidence of discrimination. Ask about the schedule and essential functions instead.
Source: EEOC, Job applicants and the ADA; EEOC, Pre-employment inquiries (marital status, children)
Ordering a background report without notice and permission
When you use a background check company, the FCRA requires a stand-alone written notice and written permission before you get the report.
Rejecting someone over a report without the notices
The FCRA requires a notice with a copy of the report and the summary of rights before the decision, and an adverse action notice after it.
Blanket criminal record rules not tied to the job
The EEOC warns against exclusions that disadvantage protected groups and do not predict who will be a safe, reliable employee. Follow any exclusions your state requires, and tie the rest to the job.
Source: EEOC and FTC, Background checks: what employers need to know
Treating caregivers as contractors without checking the tests
Worker status depends on control of the work, not the label. Check the IRS guidance and your state’s tests before you decide.
Skipping Form I-9 or the new hire report
Form I-9 is required for every new employee, and new hires must be reported to the state where they work.
Source: USCIS, Form I-9; ACF, New hire reporting
Your state sets the details. Federal rules set a floor for recruiting, background checks and hiring paperwork. States and cities can add their own rules, such as caregiver background checks, registry listings, training before client contact, limits on how criminal history is used, and wage rules. Check with your state licensing agency and state labor agency. For licensing items, homecarelicenseguide.com, also published by Home Care Agency Blueprint, collects each state’s sources.
What to do next
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common hiring mistake?
We do not have data on that, so we will not guess. The federal rules cited here make consistent questions, the FCRA notices and complete paperwork the steps most worth getting right.
Want to talk through your options?
A free 15-minute clarity call with Home Care Agency Blueprint. It helps people start home care agencies, so expect that perspective. You do not need a hiring plan first.
Book a free 15-minute clarity call